Goodyear Lake vacation rentals

Book unique houses, vacation rentals, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Cabin in Hamden

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Mtn Spring Fed Catskills Cabin~grill+hike+fire pit

This super cozy Western Catskills cabin is all about relaxation! Soak in our clawfoot tub gravity fed by the mountain spring, curl up by the wood stove with a book, go hiking, visit breweries, covered bridges, and antique stores, get a massage, or grab a bite at one of the many local farm-to-table restaurants. Nestled between the towns of Hamden and Downsville just over two hours from the GW Bridge and only minutes to the Delaware River and Pepacton Reservoir, this cabin is your perfect getaway!

Guest favorite

Cabin in Oneonta

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Romantic Cozy Cabin with a View of the Wetlands

12 minutes from both Dreams Park and All Star Village! Perfect for a couple's getaway, a writing retreat, or a cozy home base to explore the area! This cabin was built in the 18th century but has all the modern amenities. It has an adorable fully-equipped kitchen, a charming wood interior, a vaulted ceiling, and a spacious outside deck with a view of the birdlife and wetlands. Swimming, hiking, and fishing on Goodyear Lake, 5 minutes away! Minutes from live music, cafes, and antique shops!

Guest favorite

Cabin in Jefferson

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Experience a magical Winter in a Catskills Lodge

Our modern log home is set up with fine things like Turkish towels, local artisan soaps & the softest sheets. The tasteful decor has an mcm vibe w/industrial touches. Wander outdoors, swim, follow a creek, slip into the forest, hike back, cook dinner in a state of the art kitchen w/ a pantry full of fun gadgets. Relax by the fireplace, sit outside & watch the stars, light a fire. We provide blankets & wood. A welcome basket & a fully stocked coffee bar for the early mornings are waiting for you.

Guest favorite

Rental unit in Oneonta

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Shellybrooke Farm walkout Apt

Baseball Families welcome. Long driveway to secluded home with private entrance to downstairs apartment. Peaceful location but only 7 miles to Oneonta, 25 miles to Cooperstown. 3 guests max. Owner resides upstairs. NO smoking or Pets. Large L-shape living/queen & twins beds area (privacy curtain) picture window with pond/ creek view, dining area, bathroom, kitchen, washer/dryer. Easy access to shopping/restaurants. Enjoy hikes, wildlife, pond, & above ground Pool. Horses/dogs/cat on property.

Guest favorite

Cabin in Walton

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

The Mill House: An Enchanting, Stream-Side Retreat

Escape and reconnect with nature at The Mill House, one of the most charming and beloved homes in the Catskills; just a 2.5-hour drive from NYC. Built in the early 1800s, this historic 1 bed/1 bath gem underwent a meticulous restoration in 2021, marrying its saw mill heritage with contemporary luxuries, including a Nest thermostat, smart speakers, keyless entry, and fast wifi. Original exposed post and beam construction and Scandinavian-inspired design make for a unique and cozy atmosphere.

Superhost

Cabin in Roscoe

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 483 reviews

Postcard Cabins Western Catskills - New York

An easy drive from the city, Postcard Cabins, formerly Getaway, is the ultimate way to experience the great outdoors. Nestled across acres of private woodlands, our tiny cabins have everything you need (AC/Heat, en-suite bathroom, fresh linens) and nothing you don’t. Featuring a private outdoor area (hello, fire pit), each cabin is designed to help you disconnect from the everyday. As part of your stay, you'll receive a complimentary allocation of provisions, like s’mores, coffee and more.*

Guest favorite

Home in Hunter

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Modern House with Mountain View @Getawind

Experience luxury and comfort in our newly built property. Marvel at the breathtaking panoramic views of Rusk mountain through floor-to-ceiling windows. Unwind in the sauna or hot tub, and gather around the fire pit for cozy evenings. Enjoy outdoor movie nights with our projector, or savor grilled delights in the patio area. Warm up by the fireplace, explore Ski resorts, Golf Clubs and more. It's the perfect retreat for families and friends. Book now and create unforgettable memories!

Guest favorite

Cabin in Hobart

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Secluded and Private Catskills Cabin with a View

Modern cabin on the mountains of the western Catskills. There is a full kitchen, dishwasher, washer/dryer, an assortment of books, board games, puzzles, and an indoor wood-burning stove. There is reliable, high-speed fiber-optic wifi. There is no TV. Note: In winter (Dec-March at least) you will NEED a vehicle with AWD or 4WD to reach the cabin. The final .75 mile of the drive is a dirt road with a couple of hills that could be difficult for an FWD vehicle to safely get up or down.

Guest favorite

Cabin in East Meredith

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Creekside rustic-modern A-frame in the Catskills

Our house is tucked into a quiet valley, perched above a creek and South-facing for all day sun! 21 acres of rushing creek, mixed evergreen and deciduous forest to explore. Firepits next to the house, and beside the creek. Nearby swimming, fishing, hiking, national parks. You’ll love our place because of the sound of rushing water, peace and solitude, and being able to truly get away from it all! The house is good for couples, groups, and pets. House insta account: hollow_cabin

Guest favorite

Cottage in Milford

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

At Home Base Yellow Cottage

Enjoy the Cooperstown experience while having all the comforts of home. The Baseball Hall of Fame (6 miles), Brewery Ommegang (5.4 miles), and The Cooperstown Dreams Park (0.5 miles) are all conveniently located. Scenic views from the large-covered deck of the rolling hills set on 20 acres. Check out all of the amenities including high speed internet, central air, and a BBQ grill. View our other “Home Base” listings here on Airbnb, all in the vicinity of one another.

Guest favorite

Cabin in Otego

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews

Catskills Over Water Bungalow on Lake Albanese!

Catskills Cabin Rentals has designed and built one of the most unique places in the Catskills. Located on Lake Albanese is New York's first Over Water Bungalow featuring 2 bedrooms 1.5 bathrooms. The living room has a wood burning fireplace made with handcrafted stone. In front of the fireplace the home has a glass floor to see fish, turtles, frogs, and more! The home is located on 200 acres with only 3 other log cabins.

Guest favorite

Place to stay in Oneonta

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Creekside of the Moon A-frame Cabin

Creekside of the moon A-frame glamp. Float, fish and play in the Catskills. Glamp on the Charlotte Creek in a newly built modern tiny a-frame. Sleep under the full moon. A giant moon light hangs over the bed(s) with a stunning reflection in the window at night over the creekview. Perfect for a romantic getaway, fishing trip, or glamping spot in the Catskills. Close to Cooperstown, NY IG @aframe_moon