Vacation rentals in Paradise Hill

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Paradise Hill

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Home in Fort Gibson

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

The Ranch Guest House

Welcome to the Ranch! This is not a commercial hotel property. If that is your expectation, this may not be for you. Read ALL of the listing. A continued restore of a 100 year old wood frame house on an operational ranch near historic Fort Gibson, Oklahoma. Room to park, spread out indoors - enjoy the natural views! Located between Ft. Gibson & Tahlequah across from the Cherokee State Wildlife Mgt Area less then 30 min to Lakes, Casinos, Illinois River, & more that this area has to offer.

Superhost

Home in Paradise Hill

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Paradise Hill Retreat!

Paradise Hill gem! Just up the hill from lake access at Strayhorn Marina and the State Parks on both sides of the lake. Soda Steve's, Fin and Feather, disc golf, Mexican food, hiking trails, DG, Illinois River fishing and float trips are ALL nearby. This house is one of the newest in Paradise Hill. Huge covered patio in front plus a dining and grilling patio in back. Split floor plan with large kitchen and living in the middle of it all. Oversized garage. When you come, you won't want to leave!

Guest favorite

Tiny home in Tahlequah

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

The Spring House Tiny Home near the Illinois River

Get cozy and settle into this rustic space! This cozy tiny home is perfect for couples looking to get away from it all. Overlooking the scenic Needmore Ranch and featuring a working water wheel powered by the nearby Stephen's Spring, the Spring House Tiny Home is perfect for couples reconnecting with nature, accessing the nearby Illinois River, or relaxing with that significant other. Guests will have access to over 400 acres of private property to hike, explore, or view the local wildlife.

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Cookson

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

The Nook @ Cookson—Night, week or monthly stays

Newly remodeled garage apartment in the Cookson area just minutes from Lake Tenkiller. Beautiful park like setting with an abundance of wildlife. Short drive to Cookson Bend Marina and The Deck (music, food and drinks). Plenty space to park your boat. Enjoy fishing, boating or float the Illinois river in Tahlequah. Has refrigerator, microwave, Keurig coffee, hot plate w/ pot and pan, Smart TV with WIFI. Queen bed & twin sofa bed." Outdoor amenities -gas grill, patio furniture and a fire pit.

Guest favorite

Home in Park Hill

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 260 reviews

Cozy 💥Casual Comfort💥with Room for everyone!

Come & enjoy S’mores by the fire! Crane Cottage is designed for comfort, fun and privacy! Hard Wood Floors, oversized fluffy furniture, fireplace for ambience & tons of amenities! All located less than 1 mile to Lake Tenkiller access! Full service Restaurant & Convenient Store w/Deli next door! Oklahoma Station/Home of Juicy Pigg BBQ 2 miles away, Big Reds Restaurant 4 miles. 12 minutes to Tahlequah, home of Cherokee Nation Tourism! Sam & Ellas Pizza/Cantino Bravo,& fun local boutiques

Guest favorite

Cabin in Gore

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Trout River Lodge: River Run Cabin

Escape to a serene landscape on a private 5 acre lot with private access to the Illinois River, renowned for trout bass fishing and duck hunting. Fishing is available all seasons on a stocked river. Private access with stunning walk to a private water access for the family. Newly renovated cabin offers traditional cabin esthetics with contemporary amenities, antique lighting and furniture. Trout River Lodge offers family-friendly retreat for 8-12 people or nice couples getaway adventure.

Guest favorite

Home in Paradise Hill

5 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Hot Tub With a Winter Lake View

Hidden away in the Paradise Hill neighborhood on a secluded, wooded lot, this property was completely renovated in 2024 and comes with a peekaboo view of Lake Tenkiller from the new hot tub. It's a 6 minute drive to Strayhorn Marina, a 22 minute drive to Barnacle Bill's, and less than a mile to the Fin and Feather Resort and Soda Steve's. Relax inside with family board games, cook a meal in the fully stocked kitchen, or just unwind in front of the Roku TV with 1 gig internet speed.

Guest favorite

Home in Paradise Hill

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

Britton Home/Paradise Hill Tenkiller w/Boat Slip

This beautiful newly renovated log home sits on Paradise Hill overlooking Lake Tenkiller. It is minutes away from the Fin and Feather Resort and Soda Steves Restaurant. The house also comes with a boat stall for guests to park their boat while they are staying. The boat stall is minutes from the house, an easy walk or drive. The home features 2 large decks for sitting and a covered outdoor kitchen with a fire stove for cooking. Guests can unload boats at Strayhorn Marina.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Paradise Hill

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Lake Tenkiller, Paradise Hill Area, Strayhorn Area

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. The Trout Catcher is 1 mile from Strayhorn Marina on Tenkiller Lake, right across the street from Fin & Feather & Soda Steve's, and 2 miles from the best trout stream in Oklahoma. There is plenty to enjoy in this area. Come enjoy this cozy cabin on Tenkiller Lake. Whether it is out on the deck grilling or inside playing cards with family or friends, this is a peaceful place to get away.

Guest favorite

Home in Gore

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 188 reviews

Main Street Cottage

A charming cottage built in 1912. Our house is perfect for you while you vacation at the lake, fish on the river, just sit on the porch, soak up the WiFi or visit friends and family. There is room to hang out together or spread out. A pull through drive long enough for your boat or trailer. Small town, restaurants, coffee shop, shopping and minutes from Lake Tenkiller, Arkansas and Illinois rivers, Tenkiller State Park, Greenleaf State Park.

Guest favorite

Cabin in Paradise Hill

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

The Guide House - Cottage-feel Cabin w/ Lake View

Welcome to a paradise near Paradise Hills! Whether you are looking to slow down and relax or enjoy all the lake has to offer, the Guide House is the place for you! This modern A-frame cabin will welcome you with a serene, open concept interior with cottage touches throughout, tons of natural light, and a large deck with a treetop lake view of Tenkiller. Just a hop, skip, and a jump from Fin N' Feather, Soda Steve's, and Strayhorn Marina.

Guest favorite

Home in Muskogee

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Modern Country Gem/Huge Yard/Coffee Bar/King Bed

The Muskogee "Country Gem" is your touch of modern country ambiance! Your comfortable home away from home located at the end of a cul-de-sac. Super clean, professionally decorated, well-appointed and just minutes to downtown. Don't miss the beauty of Honor Heights Park or the various events at The Castle of Muskogee. Learn about local music legends at the Oklahoma Music Hall of Fame.