Anastasia Island vacation rentals

Book unique vacation rentals, houses, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Anastasia Island

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Guest suite in St. Augustine

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

Saint Augustine Beach House

Conveniently located between both St. Augustine pier and Crescent beach. Walk or bike ride up the road 1/4 mile to the beach. Great area and neighborhood. Keypad private entrance for self check-in. First floor is all yours and sealed off from the upstairs in this 2 story home. One very large bedroom, living room, kitchen and full bath. It features a new king sized bed along with a 3 inch memory foam topper. This can be broken down into 2 separate xl twins if needed. Front and back decks.

Guest favorite

Cottage in St. Augustine

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

BambooLane Hideaway-Night of Lights 1.2mi to DWNTN

Sophisticated, tropical hideaway. Your retreat, quiet, respectful & peaceful. All are welcome here with love and respect. Perfect for singles, couples, looking to rest and relax or to explore this historic Florida shore, the ‘Bamboo lane hideaway’ offers unique accommodations complete with a custom-designed interior and laid-back beach vibe. One thing to consider before booking is that our place is tiny but mighty. Complementary bikes to Explore the Lighthouse, Zoo, Beaches, AMP, & Downtown.

Guest favorite

Guest suite in St. Augustine

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 410 reviews

Winter Hawk Hideout

15 minutes from ol' St Augui. Located in the heart of this typical Florida woods and nested by oaks that saw the Seminole War as we are walking distance from Ft Peyton and 2 miles away from where Osceola was captured. The house sits on half acre of gardens and the decor is ranch, asian and whimsical .The goal is for you to feel transported away for a while. I do have 2 very small, well behaved and quiet dogs and one never seen cat. They do not have access to your quarters or are allowed in.

Guest favorite

Guest suite in St. Augustine

5 out of 5 average rating, 232 reviews

Entire guest suite short walk to beach.

Enjoy exploring beautiful, historical St. Augustine then kick back and take it easy at this private, quiet beach retreat within a short walk to the beach. Separate keyless entry allows for self check-in. Queen size bed, fully furnished, with amenities including a Keurig coffee maker, iron, hair dryer, beach cruiser bicycles, beach chairs, towels, umbrella and gas grill for cooking out. Flat screen TVs in both the living room and bedroom with Netflix and Amazon Prime included and Free WiFi

Guest favorite

Home in St. Augustine

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 216 reviews

Private Romantic Old Florida Style Cottage

Private Romantic Cottage in flower filled garden with mature trees. Cathedral ceiling, fireplace, full kitchen, large shower with two shower heads, queen bed, lots of off street parking, two large decks, outdoor shower, maple wood floor. A perk: Free parking Spot Close to Downtown included at a different property. You have this entire property to yourself. In the serene Historic Fullerwood Neighborhood. Beautiful architectural details make this a memorable place to stay. Perfect for couples.

Guest favorite

Townhouse in St. Augustine

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Penthouse Artist Haven Ocean front Penthouse

Nestled along a pristine stretch of semi-private beach is this historic artists haven offering an absolute beachfront location like no other. This unique home is split into 3 separate floors, where you will be renting the entire top penthouse level. Inside you will find open studio living with a luxe king bed and a front and rear balcony. Enjoy uninterrupted ocean views from the panoramic windows while you relax & watch dolphins play in the surf and stunning sunsets spread across the sky.

Guest favorite

Condo in St. Augustine

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

++Perfect Romantic Getaway - Walk to the Sea

Our Condo by the Sea bids welcome from Anastasia Island! All modern amenities. Looking for a Romantic Getaway by the Sea? Relax and really unwind! This is the getaway you have been looking for. Located right on gorgeous, white sand Crescent Beach, a couple minute's walk from your gated condo, and only 15 minutes drive up A1A to The Historic District of St. Augustine and the nightlife of the City! Close to everything. Fabulous dining and historic sights. Come to our Condo and be amazed!

Guest favorite

Rental unit in St. Augustine

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

A1A Beach Retreat Unit D - Clean Full Apartment

This centrally located getaway in St. Augustine Beach is perfect for your dream vacation! Featuring 2 queen bedrooms, 1 bath, and a sleeper sofa, it’s just a short walk to the beach, local dining, and lively watering holes. Only 5 miles from historic downtown St. Augustine, you’ll be close to all the action. Enjoy 2 reserved compact parking spaces for hassle-free beach access. This isn’t just a rental—it’s your ticket to a laid-back coastal lifestyle. Book now and start your adventure!

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in St. Augustine

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 275 reviews

Tiny House three blocks from beach!

The tiny house at the Crescent Beach house is a one bedroom one bath detached guesthouse ! The bedroom includes a queen bed and closet. There is a great kitchen with a full size stove/oven, keurig, and microwave. Wifi and a large TV with Netflix only, no cable. Beach chairs, towels, and umbrella included! Soak in the great Florida beach lifestyle. There’s a board walk beach access at the end of the street ! This tiny house is adjacent to a two story home which is a separate Airbnb!

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Saint Augustine

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 694 reviews

Beach and Serenity

6 BLOCKS to BEACH, off of the intercostal! Studio apartment, sleeps up to 4. Quiet neighborhood, close to all. Several restaurants/shops within walking distance. Beach bikes included, perfect for bike rides along the beach. Private entrance off of porch, which includes chairs to relax in, beach toys, towels, chairs. *yes, we are pet friendly, however, ONE PET PER STAY WITH APPROVAL *also, we cannot split weekends, so please book accordingly, fridays and Saturdays booked together

Guest favorite

Rental unit in Saint Augustine

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 369 reviews

Charming "Treehouse" apartment

Let this unique 1 bdrm/1 bath (w/ claw-footed tub) apartment provide the relaxation and comfort you should expect when on vacation. The bedroom has a comfy queen-sized mattress and the black recliner in the living room has the potential to lull you into a dreamy state when you're not out exploring! The treehouse is close enough to attractions/beach/restaurants to walk or ride bikes (We have an assortment of bikes and beach paraphernalia for your use). Three day minimum.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Saint Augustine

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 328 reviews

Sea La Vie Beach Studio

Our renovated studio is on a quiet cul-de-sac, one block from the beach! It is one side of a duplex and is perfectly located within walking distance to restaurants, family-friendly activities, nightlife, and public transport. It is across the street from the pier and the piers weekly farmers market. It is a short drive to historic downtown St Augustine. The neighborhood is quiet and safe. Our place is good for couples, solo adventurers and business travelers.