Hotel vacation rentals in Lake Montauk

Find and book unique hotel rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated hotel rentals in Lake Montauk

Guests agree: these hotel rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

Hotel room in Madison

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Queen Room Cristy’s Madison #5

Smaller room with queen bed. Private bathroom, free cable/Roku, WiFi and beach access. We are a one minute walk from 2 beaches, and minutes from center of town, shopping and various weekly town events. Common area with coffee and water, downstairs is a full restaurant with breakfast, lunch and dinner. Maid service not provided. THIS ROOM IS LOCATED ABOVE A RESTAURANT AND BAR ON THE 2ND FLOOR, ACCESSIBLE BY STAIRS. THERE IS POTENTIAL FOR NOISE, ESPECIALLY ON THE WEEKENDS.

Superhost

Hotel room in Montauk

4.53 out of 5 average rating, 484 reviews

Ocean Front Resort Private decks Pool & Beach

The sun, the sand, and the surf meet at the Wavecrest Resort to offer a magical holiday to our guests. Studio rooms offer EITHER 2 Queen size beds OR 1 queen bed and a sleep sofa. All have a kitchen efficiency, Private deck and Ocean View. On site food truck for Breakfast, Lunch & Snacks, Media/ Game room available, Heated Pool, BBQ's, Beach bon fires, Complementary Beach Lounge Chairs and Umbrellas, Free Shuttle to town July thru Labor Day. Perfect Place to Relax!

Guest favorite

Hotel room in New Shoreham

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Old Bakery Inn 2 Bedroom Suite. Pet Friendly

RECENTLY UPDATED! The Old Bakery Inn 2 bedroom suite features 1 King bedroom and 1 Queen bedroom with 1 bathroom. New plush bedding, pillows and duvets. Coastal decor and updated TV's and other amenities. Private deck with afternoon sun or enjoy views of Old Harbor from waterfront balcony. Watch the ferries come and go. Located in the heart of downtown and walking distance to the shops, restaurants, bars and beaches. Beach chairs and towels provided, pet friendly.

Superhost

Hotel room in Aquebogue

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Aqua - Superior King Garden View - Adults Only

Located in the heart of Long Island’s wine country, Aqua by American Beech is just 1 ½ hours from Manhattan. You can find more than 50 wineries to enjoy and guests are in close proximity to all Hamptons and North Fork villages a. The guest has to pay taxes and resort fee, $35 per night at the check in. Semi pet friendly hotel, we accept one dog under 50 pounds and cannot be alone in the room, a $110 pet fee will be add to your final bill. Check in starts at 4pm

Guest favorite

Hotel room in mystic

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Downtown Mystic Suite with fireplace, king, futon

Located in the heart of downtown Mystic in the Historic District, this charming suite offers everything you need for a relaxing stay. This 600 sq ft suite has a king bed, futon, fireplace, kitchenette and private bath. There is a beautiful brick terrace and gardens behind the Carriage House with a fire pit, bbq, and plenty of seating. Leave you car behind as everything Mystic has to offer is just a short 3 minute walk. There is off street parking as well.

Superhost

Private room in Montauk

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Oceanfront & private balcony at Royal Atlantic

Drop your bags and hit the beach from this 1st floor ocean front accommodation in the Royal Atlantic Beach Resort. Resort amenities include 2 in-ground heated amazing pools looking over the ocean, direct ocean access, onsite restaurant, free parking, beach bar with food concession and game room. Located on the Atlantic ocean 1 block from the Village of Montauk with all it has to offer.

Guest favorite

Hotel room in Montauk

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Montauk OceanEnd 5

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Ocean front 1 bdrm apt with gorgeous furnishings. Space was completely renovated with no expense spared. Ocean front and a few blocks to the heart of town. This unique spot will make you feel like you’re in another realm. Come and grab your slice of heaven! Taxes collected @14.625percent week of stay.